PLEASANT VALLEY, N.Y. – Pleasant Valley Highway Superintendent John Baxter has been arrested on a felony charge of unlawful surveillance, following a police investigation launched after town officials discovered suspicious recording equipment in a municipal office.
Discovery of Surveillance Device
The case began on August 1, 2025, when town officials reported finding a camera or other recording device hidden under the desk of a town employee. The discovery raised immediate concerns and was reported to the Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office (DCSO), prompting an official investigation.
Leave of Absence and Timeline
According to Town Attorney Brooke Youngwirth, who handles labor and employment issues, discussions between the town and Baxter took place soon after the discovery. On August 4, officials requested that Baxter step aside from his duties, and Baxter agreed to take a voluntary leave of absence.
Initial reports incorrectly suggested that Baxter had been arrested before taking leave. However, authorities confirmed that he was not arrested until August 11, when investigators charged him with felony unlawful surveillance. Town officials were notified of the arrest the following day.
Arrest and Charges
The Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office confirmed Baxter’s arrest but did not release further details about the nature of the recording device, how long it may have been in place, or whether additional evidence had been recovered.
The charge of unlawful surveillance is a serious felony under New York State law, carrying potential prison time if convicted. It typically involves the use of a device to secretly record or observe individuals without their consent, particularly in areas where privacy is expected.
Town Response
Town leaders emphasized that they acted swiftly once the device was discovered.
“The Town of Pleasant Valley is committed to maintaining transparency and accountability,” said Town Supervisor Mary Albrecht in a statement. “However, due to the ongoing nature of the investigation, the Town cannot comment further on the matter at this time, and we appreciate the public’s understanding and patience as the case proceeds through the judicial system.”
Officials also noted that the town is fully cooperating with law enforcement to ensure the matter is handled appropriately.
Impact on Highway Department
With Baxter on leave and now facing criminal charges, day-to-day operations of the highway department have been handed over to the department’s working foreman, who is overseeing municipal road and infrastructure responsibilities in the interim.
Baxter, an independently elected official, has so far declined to comment publicly on the allegations.
What Comes Next
Baxter is scheduled to appear in court later this month, where the case will move forward through preliminary hearings. Legal experts note that the upcoming court date may provide more details about the evidence gathered and how prosecutors intend to proceed.
Until then, the future of Pleasant Valley’s highway leadership remains uncertain, and the case has left the community with lingering questions about accountability, trust, and oversight in local government.
Leave a Reply