When people think of Jack in the Box, their minds usually jump to the West Coast—California, in particular. Known for its quirky ads, iconic tacos, and diverse fast-food menu, the chain is a mainstay in the Southwest and West. But what many don’t realize is that Jack in the Box once had a presence in New York, and more specifically, right in the heart of the Hudson Valley.
A Surprise Discovery: Jack in the Box in the Hudson Valley
While researching Jack in the Box’s expansion efforts across the country, news recently broke that the company plans to re-enter the Chicago, Illinois market after a 40-year absence, with up to 10 new locations in and around the Windy City. That sparked conversations and curiosity—could Jack in the Box make a similar return to New York?
As it turns out, it wouldn’t be the first time.
The Forgotten Newburgh Connection
According to a nostalgic Facebook group called Remembering Newburgh New York, there was once a Jack in the Box located in the City of Newburgh during the 1970s. It was reportedly situated at the corner of Fullerton and Broadway, a busy intersection that would have given the location prime visibility and foot traffic at the time.
Though the location eventually shut down, the memories have lived on for decades in the hearts of local residents. In the comment section of that post alone, over 60 people chimed in, reminiscing about late-night visits, after-school meals, and their favorite menu items.
A Taste That Lingers
Many of the locals who fondly remember the Newburgh Jack in the Box still crave the taste today. One Newburgh resident recently shared that while on a trip to the West Coast, they stopped by a Jack in the Box restaurant out of pure nostalgia—and were delighted to discover that “the tacos taste the same as I remembered!”
Legendary WPDH radio DJ Robyn Taylor, a lifelong Newburgh native, shared a similar sentiment. She recalls ordering “two tacos and a breakfast jack” as her go-to meal. In fact, her first-ever taco came from that very location on Broadway—an experience that clearly left an impression.
Could Jack In The Box Return To Newburgh?
With Jack in the Box now testing expansion into new territories—such as Illinois—it begs the question: Could Newburgh or the Hudson Valley see a revival of the brand? It’s been nearly 50 years since the last Jack in the Box graced the streets of Newburgh, but given the loyalty and nostalgia from former customers, there might be a built-in fanbase waiting.
There’s also precedent. Other major fast-food chains have successfully returned to markets after decades-long absences, driven by local demand and favorable business conditions. The Hudson Valley, with its growing population and a mix of urban centers and suburban communities, could be a viable candidate.
Jack in the Box’s Nationwide Challenges
While expansion is on the horizon, Jack in the Box also announced that it plans to close between 150 to 200 locations nationwide, as part of a strategic realignment. These closures are aimed at underperforming stores and consolidating operations—but it doesn’t mean the chain isn’t seeking growth opportunities in new areas where demand is stronger.
So while store closings might sound like bad news, it could actually open the door for new regional growth in underserved or nostalgic markets like Newburgh.
Final Thoughts
The idea of a Jack in the Box in New York may sound like a novelty today, but for Hudson Valley residents—particularly those from Newburgh—it was once a delicious reality. With the chain now expanding eastward again after decades, the thought of a return to the region isn’t as far-fetched as it once seemed.
As one former customer put it, “I just want those tacos again.”
And maybe—just maybe—Newburgh will get them.
Leave a Reply