PLEASANT VALLEY, N.Y. — Pleasant Valley Highway Superintendent John Baxter was arrested earlier this month following a police investigation that began when town officials reported the discovery of potential illegal surveillance equipment in a municipal office.
Report of Suspicious Device
According to town records, the incident came to light on August 1, 2025, when officials notified the Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office (DCSO) after a hidden recording device — believed to be a camera — was discovered beneath the desk of a town employee.
The discovery immediately raised concerns about employee privacy and workplace safety, prompting law enforcement to open an investigation into the matter.
Leave of Absence Requested
Just days later, on August 4, Pleasant Valley officials requested that Baxter temporarily step aside while the investigation continued. Baxter, who is an independently elected official, agreed and took a voluntary leave of absence.
Town Attorney Brooke Youngwirth, who oversees labor and employment matters, confirmed the decision, stating that the arrangement was made to allow the highway department to continue operations without interference while investigators gathered evidence.
Arrest and Charges
On August 11, 2025, following further inquiry, Baxter was formally arrested on a felony charge of unlawful surveillance. Town officials were notified of his arrest the following day.
The charge stems from allegations that Baxter knowingly used surveillance equipment to record individuals without their consent, a crime under New York State law. If convicted, the felony carries serious legal consequences, including potential prison time.
Town Response
Town Supervisor Mary Albrecht addressed the matter in a public statement, emphasizing the municipality’s commitment to transparency.
“The Town of Pleasant Valley is committed to maintaining transparency and accountability,” Albrecht said. “However, due to the ongoing nature of the investigation, the Town cannot comment further on the matter at this time, and we appreciate the public’s understanding and patience as the case proceeds through the judicial system.”
Officials noted that in Baxter’s absence, the department’s working foreman has assumed day-to-day management responsibilities to ensure highway operations continue without disruption.
Pending Court Appearance
Baxter has not responded to requests for comment regarding the allegations. He is scheduled to return to court later this month, where additional details about the case may be revealed.
Clarification on Reports
Mid-Hudson News confirmed that earlier reports suggesting Baxter was arrested prior to his leave of absence on August 4 were incorrect. The timeline clarified by town officials shows that his arrest occurred a week later, on August 11, after the Sheriff’s Office gathered evidence from the initial complaint.
Community Impact
The arrest has left many Pleasant Valley residents with questions about trust in local leadership, as Baxter has served in an elected position overseeing the town’s highway department. While some residents have expressed shock at the allegations, others say they are waiting for the judicial process to run its course before drawing conclusions.
The case is expected to draw continued attention as the investigation develops and court proceedings move forward.
Leave a Reply