Pleasant Valley, N.Y. – Town Highway Superintendent John Baxter, an independently elected official, is facing serious legal trouble after being charged with felony unlawful surveillance. Authorities allege Baxter placed a hidden camera beneath the desk of a female town employee, prompting both outrage and swift action from local officials.
Leave of Absence from Duties
On August 4, 2025, the Pleasant Valley Town Board asked Baxter to take a leave of absence while addressing what was described as a personal legal matter. Baxter agreed to step aside, and since then, the department’s working foreman has been handling the day-to-day operations.
Town Supervisor Mary Albrecht confirmed that Baxter’s leave remains in effect as of August 16. The decision, she emphasized, was necessary to ensure the smooth functioning of the highway department while the investigation and court proceedings move forward.
Criminal Charges and Court Proceedings
Law enforcement arrested Baxter earlier this month after discovering the hidden device. He has been formally charged with felony unlawful surveillance and is scheduled to appear in court later this month.
The allegation, if proven, could carry severe consequences not only for Baxter’s career but also for his standing as an elected official. Felony charges in New York can result in prison time, fines, and removal from public office.
Town Officials Respond
Supervisor Albrecht addressed the situation publicly, underscoring the town’s commitment to transparency while also stressing the need to let the legal process unfold.
“The Town of Pleasant Valley is committed to maintaining transparency and accountability,” Albrecht said in a statement. “However, due to the ongoing nature of the investigation, the Town cannot comment further on the matter at this time, and we appreciate the public’s understanding and patience as the case proceeds through the judicial system.”
Her comments reflect the delicate balance local officials must maintain between informing the public and avoiding interference with an active case.
Community Impact and Concerns
The incident has sparked concern among town employees and residents, who are awaiting more information as the case develops. Allegations of workplace surveillance raise significant privacy and trust issues, especially in government offices where accountability and integrity are paramount.
For now, the highway department continues its work under interim leadership. While day-to-day operations remain unaffected, the town faces lingering questions about oversight and the potential fallout from the case.
Awaiting Baxter’s Response
Baxter has not yet publicly addressed the charges. Attempts to reach him for comment following his arrest were unsuccessful. His silence leaves the community with unanswered questions as the court date approaches.
As the investigation moves forward, Pleasant Valley residents and officials alike are bracing for developments that could determine the future of one of the town’s elected leaders.
Leave a Reply